Daddy Issues and a Poolside Affair Between Stepdaughters

Rick’s daughter Amy had been coming over to use our pool since she met my daughter Sara in the third grade. I’ve watched her grow up, and out, along with my daughter. Rick’s wife and mine are both very well endowed and passed that on to our girls.

I’ve been a very bad dad and couldn’t keep my nasty thoughts in check. My wife knows that if I’m watching the girls at the pool in the afternoon, she’s in for a royal fuck that evening.

I even think she has taken to buying Sara more and more revealing swim suits over the years. When I talked to her about it one evening in the after glow of some excellent sex, she just shrugged her shoulders and smiled. I warned her that she might take it too far one day, and I’m only human. She snuggled up against me and threw one leg over mine, hunching what should have been her sated sex against my thigh.

The words out of her mouth as she drifted off to sleep while wrapped around me gave me another hardon. “That’s ok, I always had a crush on my daddy too.”

****************

When Amy showed up that afternoon, I had to tell her that Sara and her mother left to visit my mother-in-law.

She pouted, and asked why she couldn’t swim anyway. I said sure and made us a pitcher of lemonade while she changed.

When she came out of the bathroom, I almost dropped the pitcher. She was wearing a one piece bathing suit, but it was too small for her and had a very famous cartoon mouse on it. Obviously it was for a younger girl than Amy. She had also braided her long hair into two pigtails to keep them out of way while she swam, adding to the little girl effect. Sexy, curvy little girl with large knockers!

She looked down where her breasts were almost falling out of the sides and where it pulled up very tight against her crotch.

“My aunt brought this back from (NAME OF FAMOUS MOUSE BASED THEME PARK). She still thinks I’m twelve.” She giggled, sending ripples through her body that threatened to dislodge her barely covered breasts. “Mom said I had to wear it a couple of times so I didn’t have to lie to my aunt.”

She dove into the deepest part of the pool as I had to sit down. My dick was hard as a rock, and I wasn’t sure she hadn’t seen it.

After a few minutes she emerged from the pool and came over for some lemonade. Dry, it had been tight. Wet, her suit showed everything. Her nipples had hardened in the pool and I could see they were huge. He suit made the most obvious camel toe and I swear I could make out a rather large clit.

As she drank her glass, I couldn’t stop. I started to rub myself through my shorts. She sat her drink down and came over in front of me.

“Like what you see?” She began to rub he sides of her breasts and push them together. I moaned and shook my head. She laughed. “Your shorts say otherwise.” She put her hand inside her suit top and began to massage herself.

“Your daughter and I have been talking.” The mention of my daughter made me stop stroking myself. “We agreed we both loved our daddies, but it wouldn’t be right to act on our feelings. However there is no reason why we couldn’t express our love by proxy. Remember that old movie where the two guys swap murders?” She pulled her breasts out of each side of the suit with the material bunching up in the valley between them. “Well Sara and I decided to swap fathers.”

She sat on the lounge beside me and began to kiss me while unbuttoning the Hawaiian shirt I was wearing. When she removed it, she pressed herself against me and I could feel her hard nipples on my chest.

She removed my hand from the front of my trunks and slipped her own hand inside.

She held me tight and whispered in my ear, “I want my first time to last, so I’m going to make you cum now. Think I can do that?” I nodded, not being able to speak. She giggled.

“I want you to take me to Sara’s bedroom. I want you to throw all those plush animals off the bed and onto the floor. I want you to take my virginity between the sheets of your daughter’s bed and I want you to smell her on the sheets and think of her as you cum in me.”

That did it, with a moan, I covered her stroking hand with my cream. She removed her hand from my shorts and licked it clean while she walked towards the house. “You know where I’ll be.”

I sat there stunned for a minute or so. Wobbly I got to my feet, downed a glass of lemonade wishing it was bourbon instead, then made my way to my little girl’s room.

When I arrived, Amy was in the bathroom. All the blinds were drawn and the room was quite dark. I advanced on my daughter’s bed and threw all the stupid plush animals onto the floor. After removing my sticky shorts I slid between my daughter’s satin sheets. The light in the bathroom went out and I felt rather than saw someone slip under the sheets

A warm breath on my penis caused it to stir and I could feel a tongue cleaning me off. I had never been harder. I reached down and stroked her hair and moved my hand down her back. She had removed the undersized swimsuit and I cupped the round shape of her ass. I groaned and a girlish giggle rose from under the sheets.

I felt her straddle me and a hand grabbed and stroked me against a warm, furry, wet spot. We moaned simultaneously as she slid herself down and took me into her. She still had the covers over her head.

We arrived at her hymen, and before I could even try and say anything, she pushed down and broke it. A cry escaped her lips as a groan escaped mine. I lifted up the covers and there to my surprise was my daughter Sara, impaled and bleeding on her father’s cock.

“Surprise,” she said through the pain of deflowering. “I hope you aren’t mad...”

I heard a giggle from the bathroom, but ignored it.

I reached up and took her face in my hands while wiping a tear away with my thumb. I pulled her face towards mine and kissed her on the lips. I could taste the salt of her tears along with the bubblegum flavor of her lip gloss. She opened her mouth and accepted my tongue. We french kissed for a while until she shifted and I pulled partway out of her. “OH! Wow!”

I grabbed her ass and pulled her back down. “Mmmmmm!!!”

I laughed, “It will only feel better, now start to move your ass up and down.”

On instinct, she began to bob up and down on my dick. Never going too far as to allow it to pop out. Her cunt felt fantastic over my dick, like it was trying to pull the man milk out of me.

Her eyes were closed and her cheeks were red. A flush was beginning to cover her breasts. I knew she was moments from orgasm, and I hated to interrupt her, but I had to. “Are you on any protection?” I asked.

She shook her head. “Don’t worry about it daddy.” She opened her eyes and looked into mine. I could feel the cum boiling in my balls, just waiting to be released. “My period was two weeks ago and I’m at my most fertile now.”

I stopped moving, but she didn’t. “Just a little bit more, daddy. I want you to cum in me as I cum on you.”

I couldn’t believe what I was hearing. “You want me to knock you up?” She bit her lower lip and nodded.

“YESSSSSS!!!” She yelled as she came in a gush of fluids onto my cock.

I couldn’t help it, my hips bucked upward and I peed a stream of cum right at the cervical opening of my fertile daughters womb. She continued humping me as we both came.

She passed out during this and I rolled to one side laid her down beside me. Amy emerged from the bathroom and snuggled up against my back. She took my hand and put it between her legs. “Make me cum.” she whispered. I could feel her rather large clit through the overstretched material of her undersized swimsuit. She began to hunch her crotch almost as soon as I touched her. My cock gave a halfhearted twitch as she came, but when she was done, she snuggled against my back and I was surrounded by a sexy girl sandwich. Warm and sated, I drifted off to sleep.